fix(security): enforce doctor scope on POST my/appointment (H1)

createAppointment only checked the caller held an allowed role, then booked
onto whatever doctor_uuid the request named — a doctor could book onto any
other doctor's calendar, a clinic onto doctors outside it, a secretary outside
their scope. Add canBookForDoctor(): doctor→own only, clinic→member doctors,
secretary→active scope + appointments.create permission, admin→any.

Regression: tests/Appointment/BookingScopeTest.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
hamed
2026-06-28 18:52:23 +03:30
co-authored by Claude Opus 4.8
parent ae06498a96
commit c084571bf0
4 changed files with 125 additions and 2 deletions
+3 -1
View File
@@ -385,6 +385,8 @@ Create a new appointment for a patient. Used by doctor/clinic/secretary to book
**Auth:** `IS_AUTHENTICATED_FULLY` — Roles: `ROLE_DOCTOR`, `ROLE_CLINIC`, `ROLE_SECRETARY`, `ROLE_ADMIN`
> **Scope enforced:** the caller must be related to the target `doctor_uuid`, not merely hold an allowed role. A doctor may book only onto their own calendar; a clinic only onto doctors that belong to it; a secretary only within their active clinic/doctor scope **and** with the `appointments.create` permission; admin onto any. Otherwise `403 FORBIDDEN`.
### Request Body
```json
{
@@ -415,7 +417,7 @@ Create a new appointment for a patient. Used by doctor/clinic/secretary to book
### Error Responses
| Code | HTTP | Description |
|------|------|-------------|
| `FORBIDDEN` | 403 | Role not allowed |
| `FORBIDDEN` | 403 | Role not allowed, or caller not scoped to this doctor |
| `VALIDATION` | 422 | Missing required fields |
| `DOCTOR_NOT_FOUND` | 404 | Doctor UUID not found |
| `SLOT_TAKEN` | 409 | Slot already booked |
+1 -1
View File
@@ -37,7 +37,7 @@ _None outstanding._
| # | Task | File:line | Cat | How to test |
|---|------|-----------|-----|-------------|
| H1 | IDOR write: `createAppointment` trusts request `doctor_uuid`, no scope check — any staff books onto any doctor's calendar | src/Appointment/Controller/MyAppointmentsController.php:59 | security-idor | POST `/api/v1/my/appointment` w/ unrelated doctor_uuid → expect 403 |
| H1 | IDOR write: `createAppointment` trusts request `doctor_uuid`, no scope check — any staff books onto any doctor's calendar | src/Appointment/Controller/MyAppointmentsController.php:59 | security-idor | **DONE**`canBookForDoctor()` scope gate + `tests/Appointment/BookingScopeTest` |
| H2 | No UNIQUE `(doctor_id, slot_start)` on Appointment → double-booking race (index is non-unique) | src/Appointment/Entity/Appointment.php:13 | db-unique | Concurrent POST same doctor+slot → only one persists. ⚠️ check existing dup data before adding constraint |
| H3 | `Payment.referenceId` not unique → same gateway callback credited twice | src/Payment/Entity/Payment.php:61-62 | db-unique | Persist two Payments same reference_id → 2nd rejected. (pairs w/ C1) |
| H4 | `FinancialBreakdown.payment` onDelete CASCADE on non-nullable FK → deleting a Payment destroys ledger rows; should be RESTRICT | src/Settlement/Entity/FinancialBreakdown.php:28-30 | db-ondelete | Delete a Payment w/ breakdown → expect FK restrict error, ledger preserved |
@@ -7,6 +7,7 @@ use App\Appointment\Service\SlotCalculatorService;
use App\Auth\Entity\User;
use App\Auth\Repository\UserActiveContextRepository;
use App\Clinic\Repository\ClinicRepository;
use App\Doctor\Entity\Doctor;
use App\Doctor\Repository\DoctorRepository;
use App\Secretary\Entity\DoctorSecretary;
use App\Secretary\Repository\DoctorSecretaryRepository;
@@ -59,6 +60,10 @@ class MyAppointmentsController extends BaseController
$doctor = $this->doctorRepo->findByUuid($doctorUuid);
if (!$doctor) return $this->error('DOCTOR_NOT_FOUND', 'پزشک یافت نشد', 404);
if (!$this->canBookForDoctor($user, $doctor)) {
return $this->error('FORBIDDEN', 'برای این پزشک مجاز به ثبت نوبت نیستید', 403);
}
$patient = $this->em->getRepository(User::class)->findOneBy(['mobileNumber' => $mobile]);
if (!$patient) {
$patient = new User($mobile);
@@ -269,6 +274,66 @@ class MyAppointmentsController extends BaseController
]);
}
/**
* Whether the acting user is allowed to book onto this doctor's calendar.
* The role gate alone is not enough: a doctor/clinic/secretary must be
* scoped to the target doctor, otherwise any staff user could book onto
* any doctor's calendar by passing an arbitrary doctor_uuid.
*/
private function canBookForDoctor(User $user, Doctor $doctor): bool
{
$roles = $user->getRoles();
if (in_array('ROLE_ADMIN', $roles, true)) {
return true;
}
if (in_array('ROLE_CLINIC', $roles, true)) {
$clinic = $this->clinicRepo->findByUser($user);
if ($clinic !== null && $clinic->getDoctors()->contains($doctor)) {
return true;
}
}
if (in_array('ROLE_DOCTOR', $roles, true)) {
$own = $this->doctorRepo->findByUser($user);
if ($own !== null && $own->getId() === $doctor->getId()) {
return true;
}
}
if (in_array('ROLE_SECRETARY', $roles, true) && $this->secretaryCanBookForDoctor($user, $doctor)) {
return true;
}
return false;
}
private function secretaryCanBookForDoctor(User $user, Doctor $doctor): bool
{
$dbUuid = $this->contextRepo->findByUser($user)?->getDbUuid();
if ($dbUuid === null) {
return false;
}
$clinic = $this->clinicRepo->findByUuid($dbUuid);
if ($clinic !== null) {
if (!$clinic->getDoctors()->contains($doctor)) {
return false;
}
$rel = $this->secretaryRepo->findActiveBySecretaryForClinic($user, $clinic);
return $rel !== null && (bool) ($rel->getPermissions()['resources']['appointments']['create'] ?? false);
}
$scopeDoctor = $this->doctorRepo->findByUuid($dbUuid);
if ($scopeDoctor !== null && $scopeDoctor->getId() === $doctor->getId()) {
$rel = $this->secretaryRepo->findActiveBySecretaryForDoctor($user, $scopeDoctor);
return $rel !== null && (bool) ($rel->getPermissions()['resources']['appointments']['create'] ?? false);
}
return false;
}
/**
* تعیین فیلتر نوبت‌ها برای منشی بر اساس scope فعال:
* Returns [type, entity, canView] یا null اگر رابطه‌ای پیدا نشد.
+56
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,56 @@
<?php
namespace App\Tests\Appointment;
use App\Doctor\Entity\Doctor;
use App\Tests\ApiTestCase;
/**
* POST /api/v1/my/appointment must enforce that the acting user is scoped to
* the target doctor. A doctor having the ROLE_DOCTOR role is not enough — they
* must not be able to book onto another doctor's calendar via doctor_uuid.
*/
class BookingScopeTest extends ApiTestCase
{
private function makeDoctor(): Doctor
{
$user = $this->createUser(['ROLE_USER', 'ROLE_DOCTOR']);
$doctor = new Doctor($user, 'دکتر تست');
$this->em->persist($doctor);
$this->em->flush();
return $doctor;
}
private function bookingBody(string $doctorUuid): array
{
$start = time() + 86_400;
return [
'doctor_uuid' => $doctorUuid,
'slot_start' => $start,
'slot_end' => $start + 1_800,
'patient_mobile' => '09120000000',
'patient_name' => 'بیمار تست',
];
}
public function testDoctorCannotBookOntoAnotherDoctor(): void
{
$doctorA = $this->makeDoctor();
$doctorB = $this->makeDoctor();
$this->authJson('POST', '/api/v1/my/appointment', $doctorA->getUser(), $this->bookingBody($doctorB->getUuid()));
$this->assertSame(403, $this->responseCode());
}
public function testDoctorCanBookOntoOwnCalendar(): void
{
$doctorA = $this->makeDoctor();
$this->authJson('POST', '/api/v1/my/appointment', $doctorA->getUser(), $this->bookingBody($doctorA->getUuid()));
$this->assertSame(201, $this->responseCode());
}
}